M4X'S, ATHMA'S, AND BECCA'S BIG EXPERIMENT (results inside)

[M4x]

Alright,

over the past few days us 3 have been thinking of an experiment and had put it into place already....After seeing that 'What makes a tag PRO' thread I thought of the experiment. What i did was made a tag at the best of my ability and gave it to athma to post pretending it was his -

http://www.gfxjunk.com/board/index.php?showtopic=4455

We wanted to test the theory if when a semi-pro or pro make a bad sig it will still get ranked good. So me being a moderate and athma being a semi-pro we thought this would be a good idea. The outcome kinda surprised me because most people said that it was moderate :P So just so you people know athma didnt make that tag :P, he can do so much more better then that we all know :P

[xcine]

It didn't look like he made it, to be honest. :P

[+mw.Sourcery]

well atleast now you know M4x lol

[.GJ]

lol..i can say it didn't look like athmas styles xD i commented on there too :)

[Aloe]

Yeh I also thought 'O_o' when i saw it.. It reminded me more about krisY though..
I guess we all passed the test? :P

[Marieke]

Lol :lol: Nice experiment! But I really like the outcome of it: that ppl are really telling what they think of a sig and not let them lead by a someone's name/rank/status :D

[athma]

lol.. Thanks for posting in there, guys... ^^

[M4x]

Yup thats really good....I was srsly shocked since i expected ppl to rank it like high inter at the least :P agree with marieke^

[mw.Kris]

It reminded me more about krisY though..[/b]

:o
I feel offended :(
You are now in my disrespect side :(

[Aloe]

-.-'' For Athma it wouldnt be so good no..
But people rate it mod, so for you it would be normal O_o..
The style just reminded me off you, it doesnt mean all your gfx look like it.. x.x
Im sorry if i offended you, i didnt mean it like this :S

[Flow]

well,i would have made a c4d tag like athma usually does
but meh..

[hynfaeries0]

lol, great experiment. XD

I think anonymous showrooms are a great idea.

But this was only one trial, so maybe... we don't know. XD

[Flow]

true,do this 3-5 more times
and dont make it so obvious :P

[.Nitrate.]

Oooh, you clever bastard :P Good experiment.

[chrissk84]

Nice expriment, good work.